Musing
At the center of a black hole exists a singularity. The nature of the singularity is very mysterious because, by definition, a singularity is where rigorous mathematics breaks down. Even whether we talk about it as a where or a where or a what can be unclear. But what is clear is that something about the laws of General Relativity break down in such extreme circumstances. The mathematics behind GR predict infinities that can’t be transformed away via some diffeomorphism. The majority view among physicists is that probably at scales approaching a singularity, a quantum theory of gravity is needed to understand what’s going on.
The Penrose and Hawking singularity theorems tell us that if certain conditions are met—generally an energy condition and the existence of some hypersurface with a focusing curvature (not a term of art)—we will exhibit a singularity in the spacetime. A singularity is actually rather hard to precisely define, because intuitively it’s “somewhere where the math breaks down”. Some earlier, naive, definition of singularities turned out to be merely coordinate singularities, similar to the singularity of polar coordinates at . For many years, physicists thought the event horizon of a Schwarzschild black hole (at ) was a singularity. As it turns out, the “singularity” at the event horizon was merely a property of Schwarzschild coordinates. Penrose, Hawking, Geroch and others gave us the definition of singularity, using incomplete geodesics, that we use today.
Rough Sketch
For timelike geodesic incompleteness:
- We consider a congruence of geodesics and the purely spatial tensor .
- We consider the expansion, defined as for spatial metric
- After some algebra, we obtain the Raychaudhuri Equation:
- Under the strong + weak energy conditions, we can use the Raychaudhuri equation to find that caustics form after a certain proper time has elapsed if . A caustic is a point where .
- We prove that caustics and conjugate points coincide.
- For an embedded hypersurface orthogonal to the geodesic congruence , the extrinsic curvature scalar is equal to the expansion .
- Hence, if the hypersurface has everywhere negative curvature scalar, a caustic ⇒ conjugate point will form in the orthogonal geodesic convergence within finite proper time
- Furthermore, we prove (via “rounding the bend arguments”) that beyond a conjugate point, those geodesics no longer maximize proper time.
- From the causal structure, if spacetime is globally hyperbolic, then the space of curves which connects points along the Cauchy surface and an arbitrary future point , is a compact topological space.
- A continuous function of a compact space into is bounded and obtains minimal and maximal values. The proper time is not continuous, but it is semi-upper-continuous which means that it will attain a maximal value.
- If a maximal curve exists, it must be a geodesic (geodesics are defined this way using the calculus of variations).
- If q lies beyond the conjugate point defined in point 6, then 7+8+9+10 form a logical contradiction. I.e. 6+7 shows that the curve with no longer maximizes the distance between (points on) and while points 8+9 require maximal curves to exist and point 10 says that maximal curve is a geodesic.
The only way out of the contradiction is to say geodesics are incomplete and they do not extend beyond proper time . This is basically the Hawking singularity theorem for expanding cosmologies (the big bang).
Similar arguments, but with somewhat more refined mathematics for null geodesics lead to the Penrose singularity theorems. There, we require the formation of a trapped surface rather than an entire Cauchy hypersurface with everywhere negative extrinsic curvature scalar.